70000 Tons of Metal - The World's Biggest Heavy Metal Cruise

"some music was meant to stay underground..."

Metallica Discuss the Importance of 'Master Of Puppets'

Photo of Metallica

Band Photo: Metallica (?)

METALLICA's James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich recently spoke to Masa Ito's "Rock City" TV show in Japan about their decision to play the "Master of Puppets" album in its entirety to celebrate its 20th anniversary. A couple of excerpts from the interview follow:

Hetfield: "My gut feeling is… I think 'Master of Puppets' represents a certain time in history. It was kind of the end of the Cliff Burton era in METALLICA, which is sad, but also very important. And maybe 'Master of Puppets' was the record that a lot of the early fans identified with. 'Cause after that Jason [Newsted] joined the band and then the popularity became bigger. And then the 'black' album… It was different after 'Master of Puppets'. So I think there's still an innocence about it and just a real 'fuck you, world' attitude to it still. And we weren't, I think, very influenced by all of the 'bigness' of METALLICA. Plus the songs — they have that energy, that fire; they're still youthful, but we were still growing, and the songs got grander and bigger, and [we added] more character to the songs. I think every song on that record is really good and it stands up to time."

"We had played almost all the songs live before, 'cause they were all, I guess, songs that needed to be played live. 'Orion' was the one song that we never really did live, and that seems to be one of the most fun — maybe because we didn't play it live, but… It's very emotional, even though there's no words to it, and having Rob Trujillo in the band now playing some amazing Cliff-style… it sounds better than ever. But I would say the songs themselves remind of an innocent METALLICA. The word 'innocent' in a… what kind of way?! Not stupid, but in a not tarnished, not ruined by fame. [Laughs] Even though we've tried our hardest to not be touched by popularity, it's impossible to not feel the effects of it. So the honesty and the innocence of 'Master of Puppets' — still sleeping, living at the studio; still roughing it and still having that fire. And only METALLICA on our minds — just METALLICA. Now it's different. There's family, there's a lot of things that are important in our lives. I think 'Master of Puppets' was… that was all we ever though about — ever."

"When we were going to play over in Europe, especially in the U.K., a lot of importance was put on 'Master of Puppets', and they did a CD — Kerrang! put together a CD of all these other bands — AVENGED SEVENFOLD, TRIVIUM, BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE, a lot of the new metal bands — paying tribute to 'Master of Puppets', and that inspired us to do our own tribute. But also, hearing those bands do our songs, it put a little fire in our ass to get back into it and really not be so lazy about playing. Not that we're lazy, but you kind of take for granted that, you know, we're been doing this for 26 years. We're good at this. Yeah, we are, but we can be better. And it helped us step up another level. I think what we were going to do was play 'Master of Puppets' live maybe just at Donington, or just at the indoor shows. But my idea was, hey, we've done the Download/Donington festival five times, six times. Let's do something different instead of the 'best of.' So we did it the whole tour, and it felt really good. It was a long set, but very inspiring, and it felt good to play from beginning to end the whole album."

Ulrich: "It's been fun. It's been really interesting writing the new record and going back and listening to 'Master of Puppets' — reliving it, re-learning it. Over the course of the years, we started playing some of the songs a little bit differently, and we went back and we played all the songs exactly… well, more or less… the same arrangements as on the album. We put a lot of parts back in that we had taken out over the years. And it's been interesting to write new songs while having 'Master of Puppets' kind of [on our minds] because I think it's definitely affecting us a little bit. Some of the new stuff has the same kind of… it's challenging like some of the 'Master of Puppets' stuff and maybe some of the stuff is a little bit inspired by some of it. We've been joking, obviously, in the beginning when we were trying to re-learn all the songs, if we had known 20 years ago that we would be playing the songs 20 years from then, maybe we wouldn't have made the stuff so complicated. But we kind of re-learned it, actually, faster than we thought. When we played the first show in Germany at Rock am Ring, we were very surprised about how effortless it felt, and how natural it felt to be playing the whole record, and obviously the way the fans were responding to it was very positive. They were even more surprised than we were that we could still play it, and still play it well and still feel like we were in control of it, 'cause some of the stuff is kind of complicated and nutty, but… We're all in very good shape and we've been in very good physical energy for most part of the year, so it's been fun.

"But what does the record mean? It's difficult to just highlight that record. You've done enough interviews with me to know how I feel about most of our records. I like most of our records, I have respect for all our records, certainly. I understand that people think that 'Master of Puppets' is a big highlight, but for me, it's just one of many records, and one of many records that fit a puzzle. I don't think that there could be a 'Master of Puppets' without the record before it and the record after it, and that goes for all of them, so it's difficult for me to single that record out as a special achievement, but I understand that for a lot of people it's a very special record, and I'm OK with that. But it's been a very positive experience. We've never done anything like that before — we've never played a whole record, we've never really celebrated a record — and I think we were a little bit hesitant about doing it, because I think we're scared of dating ourselves. We still consider ourselves to be younger than we are, and in our own minds, we feel that we're still much more part of the current generation than the previous generation. IRON MAIDEN and JUDAS PRIEST and AC/DC, they're still our heroes and they're still our idols, and so I still feel much more… I feel like I have much more in common with TRIVIUM and AVENGED SEVENFOLD and those bands than I do with IRON MAIDEN and JUDAS PRIEST, because they were my heroes. So it's difficult… When we did this whole 'Master of Puppets', I think we got a little scared of, maybe we were part of the older generation, you know what I mean? But I think it's been OK. And it's actually been a lot of fun to do it. Maybe we'll do it with every record as it hits its 20th anniversary. Who knows?!"

Watch video clips of James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich's appearance on Masa Ito's "Rock City" at YouTube.com: James, Lars.

Source: Blabbermouth

What's Next?


25 Comments on "Metallica Discuss Importance of Master Of Puppets"

that_one_guy_42's avatar

Member

1. that_one_guy_42 writes:

well, he kind of admitted that they didnt put very much effort into the more recent albums, and that they werent as good, it would be cool if this somehow helped them get back some of the ways they used to play. but i have trouble seeing that happening, but you never know.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 11:10 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
RememberMetal?'s avatar

Former Contributor

2. RememberMetal? writes:

If anything can help them with this next album (other than the poor response to St Anger, Rick Rubin steping in and Rob having an active role in the studio) remembering "Puppets" will.

I like hearing how the band is surprised by the "complexity" of Puppets and surprised by the fan response to the songs being played live...

I dont want Metallica to make a MOP2 like the whole Load Reload thing...but if they can use that album as a springboard and inspiration maybe they can tweak those "new songs" that have sortof been lacking before their committed to tape.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 11:38 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
illy-B's avatar

Member

3. illy-B writes:

These guys have disappointed me so bad in the last few years that I have to wonder if they will ever get back what they lost so long ago. I am surprised that lars can still play the beats on MoP because part of the reason they have gone so far down hill is Lars's crap drumming. He never learned to play properly so it phuked up his body over the years and it is apparent in the music they have been making. That said I still have this little bit of hope that Rick Rubin will help show them the light and they will put out an awesome metal album, but I am not holding my breath (Cause I would probably die). If people are interested in a different take on MoP they should try Dream Theaters live cover of the whole thing (keyboards and all) avalible at YTSEJAMRECORDS.COM.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 12:03 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

4. Popctrl writes:

haha It's funny to hear them say that they shouldn't have made it so damn complicated...Listening to it right now, by the way.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 1:13 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

5. Scorched_Earth writes:

Its weird-I wonder what would have happened if Metallica had taken the Slayer route and made the same record over and over and never tried to do anything different (IMFukingO). The thing is...they were the spearhead. Megadeth was the only other competitor of the big four at the time (Metallica, Megadeth, Slayer and Anthrax with a far trailing Exodus) and the only other band that had really started to creep into the mainstream-like it or not-the only logical conclusion was the Black Album (and personally-I don't really like that record). Certainly they could have made better records after that (I think they really were trying on 'St Anger'-they just made some bad choices), but I just wonder how dated they would sound if they had never moved past 'Justice'...?

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 3:02 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
metal2death's avatar

Supporter

6. metal2death writes:

metallica is dead its obvious that now they are gonna play like their newer/gayer influences (a7x and trivium). i hate most NEW "metal" because it all sounds like sh** with few acceptions.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 3:06 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

7. relentless austin writes:

the thing i wonder is how different things would have been if cliff had lived. he was the brains behind so much of those early records. after the tour with ozzy in '86, they were gonna be huge...period, but with cliff? one way or another, getting back in touch with the early days is probably the best thing for them, and for the hope of getting another good album out of them.
lars really does look like he's struggling through those songs, it's a shame. he should take some lessons and improve his technique, so he can pull that sh** off better.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 3:56 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

8. Reaper writes:

I think it's good to see Metallica coming back and busting their asses trying to make a great album I do think though that Metallica took a sudden change after the Master of puppets albuum because the sound just wasn't the same in the St. Anger album I feel that i hear more of Lars's drumming than anything else no trying to bring down Metallica because they are still one of the greatest bands ever but they gotta get some good sh** goin so rock on fellow metalheads

f*** YEAH

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 5:47 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Cynic's avatar

Former Contributor

9. Cynic writes:

Oh God! I just want to grab Lars and beat him into recognising how awesome pre-black album was! They need to listen to their fans damn it, f*** Avenged Sevenfold and f*** the new generation - They don't play THRASH.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 8:51 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

10. Terminator writes:

uhh...earth to metallica...MOP is one of the greatest metal albums ever...duh. it would be nice to see metallica take the time and get the complexity back. their already incorporating solos, thats step one.

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 9:54 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

11. Scorched_Earth writes:

It still has to be recognized that Metallica had choices to make. They weren't Slayer or Anthrax-Metallica was on the verge of being HUGE. They really did what they had to do-and whether you want to believe it or not-Cliff would have gone with it in one way or the other. In his last interview he was talking about how he loved REM. Musicians tend not to end up as close minded as most metal-head because they want to express themselves. Its not as simple as just make the same record over and over (unless you're Slayer-yes-that was gratuitous).

# Aug 31, 2006 @ 11:51 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

12. relentless austin writes:

right on

# Sep 1, 2006 @ 4:25 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

13. Terminator writes:

excellent point scorched_earth. and in fact it may have happened early. in an interview after puppets, the band was stating how cliff was really getting into more melodic and harmonious styles of writing. justice probably wouldnt have been as near as heavy as it turned out.

# Sep 1, 2006 @ 2:27 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

14. Battery writes:

yes...slayer gets kinda repetitive...personally i like all of metallica albums almost equally...but if i have to put them in order i would put RTL and Black on the last spots...and AJFL and MOP on the very top.

# Sep 1, 2006 @ 2:51 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

15. blakscorpion21 writes:

slayer... same albums over and over.... blasphemy. every slayer album has a unique sound except maybe the last 3. slayer is so much like metallica its not even funny.
show no mercy=kill em all: their 1st cd, rough around the edges but really good.
hell awaits= ride the lightnig: a short list of long and a$$ kicking songs.
reign in blood=master of puppets: the pinnacle of both bands careers.
south of heaven=and justice for all: not as good as rib/mop but still swesome.
seasons in the abyss=black album: the last albums where the bands kept their origional sound. and the most mainstream popular.
god hates us all=st. anger: not their best work.
christ illsusion=?new metallica cd?: a good effort, better than most of their newer albums but will it live up to expectations?

# Sep 6, 2006 @ 12:33 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

16. Scorched_Earth writes:

blakscorpion21-
'slayer... same albums over and over.... blasphemy.'

Isnt 'blasphemy' Slayer whole schtick? LOL! Sorry blakscorpion21, to each their own, but I just find Slayer boring and childish. But then again I listen more to RadioHead and Curtis Mayfield than I do Metallica. I won't go into my normal Slayer diatribe. Overall point is that Metallica was in the odd position of wanting to move forward and not being in a genre where they could. Thrash Metal has a particular vibe that doesn't allow for much variation-its angry, (pretends to be) offensive to the masses, and (pretends to be) rebelious.

Oddly enough-Metallica makes me think of when U2 tried to do the 'Pop' record-the fans were like-"play the old sh**!!!" It nearly killed U2-but it must suck to be a creative person and be stuck having to do the same thing over and over...unless you're Slayer (last one-I promise!)

# Sep 6, 2006 @ 3:06 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

17. relentless austin writes:

what's this? finally an intelligent conversation about this sh**!
i think we should all just lay off these musicians, and treat every album as an individual piece of art.
at least that's probably the way these artist look at their albums. every great artist from elvis to bob dylan to the beatles to zeppelin to metallica and slayer have had highs and lows in their career.
zeppelin was trashed for their third record, because it was blue grass and country influenced. that's one of the best records i've ever heard. dylan went electric and p***ed off all the beatnik hippies, and coincidently wrote some his greatest albums in that period. on the other hand, load and reload i don't think will be looked at as a great acheivement, so i don't know what my point is honestly.

# Sep 6, 2006 @ 3:59 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

18. Scorched_Earth writes:

relentless austin-

Props-In total agreement with you. Imagine being a 40 year man trying to relate back to when you said 'No life 'til leather-we're gonna kick some a$$ tonight!' Everything about who you are (should) keep evolving and to expect artist to stagnate...its not fair to them. This whole thing is a participartory thing-we do have to buy the records and they don't 'owe' us what we 'want.'

Trujillo was interviewed (I think it was) on the SKOM DVD and he was taking about watching the movie when it was done and how it was weird to see Hetfield going to his daughter's Ballet recital. Its weird to me that even someone that close to the band locks them into this whole-go on the road, drink, f*** chicks, be a rock star kind of vibe...they are 40 year old men, it would be sad if that's where they were...

# Sep 6, 2006 @ 4:41 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

19. blakscorpion21 writes:

get a life you pathetic sh**.

# Sep 6, 2006 @ 8:31 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

20. spycrawl802 writes:

Metallica was just trying new stuffs... thats true... If Metallica didnt change their styles and remain as the old Metallica, no one can compete them... They are unstoppable... Even we as a person, we are really tired to repeat things over and over, and they are getting old now... i hope Rick Rubin will help Metallica to produce a kickass album... to bring back some Metallica fans again. Metallica just want to prove that they can be the best on whatever things they wanna do... And i want Ozzy Osbourne to have a list of his top 10 Greatest metal bands, not like that MTV's! that really sounds SH**!

# Sep 12, 2006 @ 3:09 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

21. thisguy writes:

you are the guys who shot dimebag!!

# Sep 12, 2006 @ 5:22 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Crushem's avatar

Supporter

22. Crushem writes:

Metallica's best stuff was M.O.P- black album ok, but the newer stuff suks. can they pull off something better? A7X suks!

# Sep 15, 2006 @ 12:24 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
RememberMetal?'s avatar

Former Contributor

23. RememberMetal? writes:

Theres a difference between trying to relate to a person you no longer are and turning in half thought out crap like it's complete for 15 years.

I say this time and time again. Read the lyrics to the song "Master of Puppets" then read the lyrics to the song "St Anger".

Read them!

There is a DRASTIC, PROFOUND and SEVERE decline in quality.

The perspective, the words, the vocal delivery the progression of the character (the drug)....not to mention the music..... It's a story of a drug conquering a person, from the perspective of the drug!...It's genius, especially for it's time.

And then you have "St Anger"...Which has been done a 25,000 times this year alone. It goes in circles, like a rabid animal experiencing loss of brain function....It's something thats terrible to see(read) much less hear.

I understand James is a changed man these days but he's not stupid. He's f***ing brilliant!...But Lars' dad was -right- they should have deleted the St Anger sessions, its good that they got that album out of their system but it's filth....

I hope this next album will be the one that sets them right, I think they can do it. I do have faith.
But St Anger was the most crippling thing that band has done to itself since Load/Reload, which compared to St. Anger were at least excusable if not decent.

I don't want the old Metallica back, I don't want them to fake it either, I want them to not sound like fools trying to be something they arent.

They tried grunge/alternative, they tried nu-metal/garage rock.....Hopefully they try to be Metallica this time out.

# Sep 15, 2006 @ 2:24 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

24. still_caught_somewhere_in_time writes:

i'm a HUGE metallica fan and have been so disappointed with their new stuff that i wanna grab them by their throats and force them to hear MOP over and over again so they can remember how much they used to rock. in my personal opinion, MOP is their best album ever, no doubt in my mind. garage days is cool but after that they turned into a more 'radio friendly' band and were less underground. now they suck. after cliff died, it all went downhill for these guys but i still listen to MOP everyday, it just has this anger in it that no other album does. i just wish they would go back to their old stuff like and do new songs like it, but they're different now and they i dont think they'll change

# Sep 18, 2006 @ 10:32 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader

25. godlike writes:

I seen the Master of Puppets tour..a matter of about 6 wks before Cliff died....that was a fantastic show.....so much better than any of the last 3x I have seen them since...MOP will always be my favorite Metallica release..although Kill em All was quite good ....but after MOP, I became more of a Megadeth fan.... Dave Mustaine's a much better lyricist...OK,so he is an eccentric oddball but he knows how to put together some killer albums....and he has consistantly made good music...unlike some of Metallicas flops...

# Sep 18, 2006 @ 10:50 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address

To minimize comment spam/abuse, you cannot post comments on articles over a month old.