"some music was meant to stay underground..."

70000 Tons of Metal - The World's Biggest Heavy Metal Cruise


This is xFiruath, Officially Signing Off

My long journey with Metalunderground began nearly a decade ago. Obama wasn't President yet, and I still had a day job. I was tired of people screaming at me on the phone over problems with their cell service that I hadn't caused and had no ability to fix. It was time for a change, so the wife and I decided to give a big old middle finger to the daily grind and dive headfirst into freelancing online.

It wasn't long after getting in touch with Deathbringer that I found myself in Seattle on a tour bus shaking hands with Mikael Akerfeldt and blathering like an idiot about what a big fan I was. Its an experience I'll never forget, seeing a legend in the flesh and learning what his daily life was like while performing across the country. I was so star struck I accidentally left my audio recorder on the bus after the interview and didn't get it back until after the show. I've got a good half an hour of Mikael on the phone talking to family in Sweden that I'm never going to delete.

Never in my life did I figure I'd be talking to Kyle Gass about the death of Dio and whether there might ever be a Pick Of Destiny 2, but there I was on the phone with one half of Tenacious D chatting about legalizing drugs and how mortality sucks. Phone calls with lifelong idols like Emperor's Ihsahn and Vorph from Samael became semi-regular occurrences. I actually ended up discussing the infamous “Jesus is a cunt” t-shirt directly with Dani Filth.

The Metalunderground of those golden days feels like a completely different era now. I remember back when every Avenged Sevenfold or Slipknot thread had 150+ comments and became any given reader's personal chat room. That time Deathbringer made a forum link on the main page as an April Fool's joke (royally pissing off everyone who wanted a message board long before we actually had one) had me in stitches while fending off angry emails.

Looking back at those days, I think of shirtless Wilco and his creative grammar. Regulars like americanpatriot1 and Gorecunt keeping conversations going. InfernoNecrosis oversharing about bodily functions. KMADD and Korndogg trolling. The constant cry of “That's not Rob Zombie!!” All those times I accidentally wrote “Mike Porntoy” or “Windows Of Plague” in a headline. Branded or Kali getting into massive fights with anyone about anything. Blindgreed1 coming up with ever more inventive insults to anyone who would dare besmirch the Metalunderground name or anybody who called MU home.

If you got past the hazing phase, you were a regular – you were on of us, and that meant something. Those were the days of R10 and Wolf, Natsquatch and Cozen, BrunoHockalugie and Jackrum, Terminator and BrianSD, IrishMetal and Trendkill91, PorcupineTreeFan and IrishMetal, Fuck_A_Name and Drum_Junkie (who blessedly has stayed active). Whoever thought a grown man could look back at a forum thread titled “I'd put my tongue in her butt” and feel nostalgic?

It wasn't just the readers that made us into that powerhouse of metal though, it was also the contributors. It was Vicky bringing absurdly underground pornogrind bands to the world's attention. It was CROMCarl's pun-tastic reviews. It was James (Cynic), Zack (zMETALlica), Peggy (darkstar), Cody (The_Avant_Garde), Dan (heavytothebone2), Kevin (n0thinghead), Joel (bloodofheroes), Andrew (remembermetal?), Matt (Dasher10), psythe, and more turning this thing into a community. All the while there was Deathbringer keeping us together and introducing me to bands like Acid Bath.

Along the way I've had the distinct pleasure of running our staff voting and writing up the yearly best-of articles, chronicling an absurd number of releases and how they ranked in the metalverse. I'll never forget those dueling articles about the merits of Opeth's “Heritage” with Darren (if you think the comments we get now are negative, oh boy, you should see some of the shit that hit my inbox back then when I dared to state a negative opinion about the Swedish golden boys). There were the fabulous inverse Valentine's Day articles with Ollie, as well as meeting fascinating people who have since moved on to other endeavors like Frank (Progressivity_In_All) and Mike (OverkillExposure).

This journey of a staggering 603 reviews and just shy of 62,000 news stories has included everything from spending time talking to a band absurdly named Vaginal Penetration Of An Amelus With A Musty Carrot to moments that truly defined my life.

Although most of it took place in my home office, this has been a truly global journey, like when I had the opportunity to interview dozens of both Christian and Satanic black metal bands across the world for that unblack metal article. I got a whole new perspective on humanity while talking to people who lived through different denominations of the same religion trying to bomb each other into eternity in Croatia side by side with people who believe that prayer can literally resurrect the dead. I ended up interviewing utter misanthropes who did not want to be talking to any metal sites and were openly antagonistic, as well as extremely friendly bands who were beyond grateful someone was just simply paying attention to them.

There was the monumental undertaking of putting together our Peter Steele tribute album with bands from around the world to just simply meeting up with people I never could have imagined. Shared musical connections were forged with fans and musicians from far flung locales like Sri Lanka, Taiwan, Greece, Russia, Cyprus, Belgium, Iceland, Argentina, Israel, Chile, Norway, Maldives, the Czech Republic and even more! If it wasn't for Metalunderground, I'd never have interacted with any of those amazing musicians and metal fans.

For all those people I met online in far off lands, there were also plenty closer to home, from the trio of excellent lads in Spokane instrumental group Odyssey to local Montana scene stalwart Rashid (aka Zebulon Kosted). Probably the most surprising (and humbling) moment of my life took place right here in my own town, when the teller at my local bank saw my name and recognized who I was from Metalunderground, excitedly chatting me up about metal news.

While there were changes to the site, it was really metal itself that changed over these past 10 years. There was the appearance (and ignominious end) of djent. The love/hate phenomena that is Ghost. Pirate metal. Melodic post-hardcore (aka whiny mallcore that all sounds the same). Nu-metal's unexpected return. That God Of Atheists album that never came out (and probably never will). Watching several different bands implode in public. Hearing bands I'd adored since I was a teenager slowly turn to utter shit. Terrible fires and even terrorist shootings that took the lives of our fellow music lovers. Hilariously awesome metal covers that deserve way more attention than they ever got. Finding nobody bands from a place no one's ever heard of who could outperform absolutely anyone on the Metal Blade or Roadrunner rosters (which was hands down my favorite part of this job).

There have been huge ups and yes, some downs. There have been times when Metalunderground sat triumphantly among the top 5 metal sites in the entire world and times when we've struggled to get comments and views. The fall of MySpace, subsequent great exodus to Facebook, and rising dominance of clickbait content completely changed how music sites operate. We went from a few scant thousand Facebook followers and catapaulted to more than a million. Sometimes its good and sometimes its bad, but change happens whether you want it to or not, and sadly now those changes are leading me away from the place that's been my online home for most of my adult life.

Many of the people I've met through Metalunderground have legitimately become friends, whether its our contributors, readers, or even PR and label folks like Curtis Dewar, Tom George, and Ryan Feldman. Plenty of those friendships have gone way beyond “hey, we like the same bands” over the years. We've been there for each other through marriages, divorces, births, mental breakdowns, and even funerals (RIP DeathInEye, Godlike, and Tom Himself – the three of you will not be forgotten).

At this point, some of the people reading this post are more like family. I've given job recommendations over the phone for some of you. Regulars have emailed me asking what they can do to help our writers who were going through hard times and vice versa. When my wife and I lost our first child, there were probably more MU readers messaging me their support and condolences than anyone else – even people I'd openly argued and clashed with before. We're metal heads. No one else understands us, so we fucking stick together.

It's been my honor to serve the metal community and do my part to keep the scene thriving. I have no doubt the rest of the staff and the regular readers will keep things running smoothly. For my part, I'll now be writing for Gameskinny, working on my next fiction release, and handling a few PR campaigns for metal bands I've had the pleasure of getting to know to over the years.

I may be leaving the site, but I'm not going to vanish from the metal community, so keep in touch. For everyone reading this, whether you've been around since those heady early days or just recently got on the MU train, please know you have my thanks.

All good things come to an end, and my time here is finally done. This is xFiruath, officially signing off. Farewell Metal Underground.

xFiruath's avatar

Ty Arthur splits his time between writing dark fiction, spreading the word about underground metal bands, and bringing you the latest gaming news. His sci-fi, grimdark fantasy, and horror novels can be found at Amazon.

What's Next?

Please share this article if you found it interesting.

22 Comments on "This is xFiruath Signing Off"

Post your comments and discuss the article below! (no login required)

Jigenuck's avatar


1. Jigenuck writes:

Thank you for all these years!!

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 5:39 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
cbella's avatar


2. cbella writes:

You will be greatly missed! Good luck to you and the next chapter \,,/

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 6:36 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
CROMCarl's avatar


3. CROMCarl writes:

All the best Ty. You are the heart and soul of MU and it will never be the same. Best of luck for all your future endeavors.

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 7:11 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
deathbringer's avatar

Founder, owner & programmer

4. deathbringer writes:

What a trip down memory lane! Thanks for all your time with Metalunderground.com, Ty! Best of luck in the future.

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 11:44 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Drum_Junkie's avatar


5. Drum_Junkie writes:

Thanks for this recap of the past decade here. Best of luck with gameskinny and the new book. You will be missed around here. If there was a black metal article to be had, you were likely a part of it. This site will probably start to skew more towards tech-death and power metal as a result of the void you leave. You know, you're still welcome on the other side of the writer/commenter fence, so don't be afraid to leave a comment here and there. :)

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 4:00 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader
6. Nico / XENOKORP writes:

We will miss you, Ty!
And thanks for that time with VPOAAWAMC :)
All the best for the future!

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 7:20 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader
7. Mr Singh writes:

You quit man

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 9:11 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
RememberMetal?'s avatar


8. RememberMetal? writes:

In my younger days, I was monstrously forthright about my personal taste... The hope was that the weird sh** I liked might catch on if I acted like some gristled, obsessive, expert that (maybe I wasn't) knew what was coming next... I predicted a few band's fame before it came and considered myself a seeer.

The hope was that I might steer people to music they wouldn't inspect otherwise.

I knew authority mattered... so I brought it. I grew up with metal. Sabbath, Metallica, Slayer, Death, Tool, Megadeth... all featured heavily in my upbringing.

I recall hundreds of distinct conversations at MU... but I remember encountering xFiruath for the first time and wanting (desperately) to reevaluate my output.

Here was someone reaching people more pragmatically, poetically, but most importantly... without condescension or confrontation.

He invited you into his taste. There was no force. To this day I appreciate and envy his approach. Thank you Ty.

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 11:31 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader
9. Oldthrasherinflorida writes:

Oh man....I can't believe you're really leaving the site....I know I have been one of the persons you have clashed with on more than one thread but I always liked following your posts and articles....thanks so much for posting stuff about All Out War, one of my favorite bands that is several states away.....if it wasn't for your efforts I might have missed some of their albums and shows......anyway I don't want you to think I'm getting all emo on you(lolz) but your presence will definitely be missed by me....I'll raise a can of ale for your efforts on this site when I go see venom inc tomorrow night in orlando.....hails and horns wherever you venture to....\m/

# Sep 29, 2017 @ 11:38 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
coldiem's avatar


10. coldiem writes:

Sorry to see you go! No name-drop for me?! I guess I'm not a regular around here. LOL. Anyways, best of luck in your future endeavors!

# Sep 30, 2017 @ 12:10 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Terminator's avatar


11. Terminator writes:

I miss the dark ages of this site. All the wonderful sarcastic sh** slinging and random conversations that a ton of people would contribute to. Good times for sure.

Best of luck to you, man! Have fun hoarding mustard :P

# Sep 30, 2017 @ 5:27 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Cynic's avatar

Senior Reviewer

12. Cynic writes:

Hell of a trip down memory lane Ty. I'm laughing now just picturing wilco's avatar.

I owe you eternally for introducing me to Amorphis. And I loved the honesty in your reviews - no bullsh** and knew the audience you were writing for.

600 reviews! Awesome milestone. In the end it's people like you that keep the engine of this scene stoked. Metal is alive because we keep the torch lit and pass it on. Keep on burning my friend.

Oh and while things in life do change, seeing branded sh** on Metallica in a comment section in 2017 reminds me just like metal, some traditions never die :P

# Oct 1, 2017 @ 7:28 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Terminator's avatar


13. Terminator writes:

I miss the dark ages of this site. So much sarcastic sh** slinging and random discussions. It was a great little metal community this place had going.

Good luck to you, man. Always enjoyed reading your work here. Have fun hoarding mustard :P

# Oct 1, 2017 @ 9:48 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
BrianSD's avatar


14. BrianSD writes:

Wow, the memories of the never ending Avenged Sevenfold threads. Funny at first then annoying, Check the MySpace page, then comeback to see it was still going.

Miss the desk job (kind of) and my downtime in the middle of the day for MU. It was and still is somewhere to find a new band or one that slid past my radar. Good luck in the future! If you ever get out to Illinois check out Galena canning company, serious hot mustards!
Take Care

# Oct 1, 2017 @ 11:30 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Westfallen's avatar


15. Westfallen writes:

Long time lurker / infrequent commenter here.

Your article brought back lots of memories from all those years ago. Best of luck Xf!!!

# Oct 2, 2017 @ 10:18 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Drum_Junkie's avatar


16. Drum_Junkie writes:


# Oct 25, 2017 @ 9:30 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Blindgreed1's avatar


17. Blindgreed1 writes:

Am I still flagged?

# Oct 25, 2017 @ 9:35 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Blindgreed1's avatar


18. Blindgreed1 writes:

Yay, i'm free at last. You will be missed xFiruath, but honestly I knew this day would come. You are a talented writer and I wish you all the best in your future endeavors. As I stand in this cat box, smearing warm orange feces over myself, I recall the days of old at the mighty MU and long to revisit, but alas, my partner in crime godlike has left this earth, as well as Tom and DIE. My eyes are moist, (so is my nether-region) as I bid you farewell my friend. I will stay in touch. Even if it's to call you a pickle chugger. Cheers my friend

# Oct 25, 2017 @ 9:44 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Blindgreed1's avatar


19. Blindgreed1 writes:

Also... When is the last time we saw Cynic, Terminator and RM in the same thread? Epic farewell I tell you.

# Oct 25, 2017 @ 9:50 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Boocifer's avatar


20. Boocifer writes:

Metal Underground has been part of my daily routine for the last 12 years, I have only posted twice during this entire period, this is due too my personal beliefs regarding online activity (which I will not discuss in this post). The back and forth dialog between everyone thru these years have been entertainment & educational in so many ways. With that said, X Firuath has been an amazing source of opinion and intellectual metal wealth. Words in a single post don't express the full extent of importance of people such as xfiruath to continue the life of the metal scene. Metal is a way of life which and is carried on thru everyone involved, whether you be a musician or consumer. Those of us who love the genre and spread the history, love, dedication or music are the ones responsible for continuing the metal torch like xfiruath has done so well. The evolution of metal underground can be seen as nostalgic or times gone past....but in reality the future is in our control.
Preach and spread the greatness of metal to everyone you know......give out the metal underground site as once was given to me. The future is in our control...don't give in, don't quit....metal will never die. Mosh on! my friends!
NOW PLAYING- Dissection......Storm of the Light Bane.

# Oct 26, 2017 @ 11:14 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader
21. Irishmetal1 writes:

Hey, I got mentioned twice

I haven't checked in as often as I used to, but that's the way life goes I guess. Can't even remember the email I used for this, never mind the password.

Good luck with all that you're doing, and whatever else you go at in future man.

# Oct 28, 2017 @ 4:24 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
CorpusUpir's avatar


22. CorpusUpir writes:

Good luck dude! Always loved the articles! Horn's high salute and may the future bring you honor, valor and pride

# Oct 28, 2017 @ 1:16 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address

To minimize comment spam/abuse, you cannot post comments on articles over a month old. Please check the sidebar to the right or the related band pages for recent related news articles.