"some music was meant to stay underground..."

Headline News

Metalunderground.com's Best Of 2014 Awards Revealed

Photo of Lamb of God

Band Photo: Lamb of God (?)

What was old is now new again, as much like with Hollywood returning to Star Wars, Jurassic Park, and Terminator, metal heads had a desire for past and present to collide throughout 2014.

This was another year of major reunions and comebacks with the likes of At The Gates, Slipknot, Sanctuary, and Massacre all returning with new material. The long dead Coal Chamber also came back to life, although we won't see an actual release until next year (with varying opinions on to whether that particular resurrection was wanted or needed).

Besides all the blasts from the past, this was a year marked by spectacles in the metal world – some truly unfortunate and others less so. Heavy metal managed to hit the Facebook trending bar and gain exposure to millions when 92 year old actor Christopher Lee released his Metal Knight EP and Christmas single ”Darkest Carols, Faithful Sing.”

Tim Lambesis of As I Lay Dying was finally sentenced after being arrested back in 2013 for attempting to hire a hitman to kill his ex-wife – an act that lead to the creation of Wovenwar, featuring the remaining members of As I Lay Dying as well as a fellow ex-believer from Oh, Sleeper.

This was also the year that included Roadrunner Records botching the release of the first Opeth single from “Pale Communion” and subsequently breaking the Internet. And who could forget Wintersun's infamous rant (perhaps best summarized as “I can't possibly record an album unless its in my own personal studio that someone else has paid for”), which sent a horde of lemming-like fans to send death threats to the Nuclear Blast Facebook page?

Typical metal shenanigans aside, this was actually a solid year for metal overall even past the major reunions. Now moving into 2015, the big question marks are if that Metallica album actually comes out, when Dimmu Borgir is finally going to get around to leaking some new info, and for those of us who have been impatiently waiting since 2012 – when will God Of Atheists finally drop that debut release that we voted most anticipated two years ago?

Before any of those questions come close to getting answers, let's take a look back at what 2014 had to offer for metal fans...

Best Metal Album Of 2014

There were loads of solid albums and even a handful of really stellar ones, which led to some stiff competition in this category during our staff voting. Until the last day of voting, we ended up with a five-way tie between Triptykon, Eluveitie, Mastodon, Scar Symmetry and Behemoth before one band finally nabbed the win by a single vote:

Behemoth - “The Satanist”

This might be the first time EVER in Metalunderground.com history that our most anticipated album from the previous year was actually voted best album the following year – so congrats to Behemoth! This was an album that seemed destined for greatness from the start, forged in adversity between leukemia and lawsuits thrown in front man Nergal's way, especially after the already excellent “Evangelion” release.

While not everyone on the staff agreed that it was top of the year material – the writer who originally reviewed the album awarded it a 3.5 / 5 – most of us put it in our top 5 nominations, which is the mark of a great release with appeal regardless of personal sub-genre preferences.

Job For A Cowboy's “Sun Eater” also deserves a special mention as an album that didn't have any business being as great as it was. If we had a “Most Unexpectedly Awesome” or “Most Improved” category, JFAC probably would have won it.

Best Metal DVD of 2014

After successive wins in previous awards, Devin Townsend's two year reign comes to an end in 2014 as Hevy Devy finally gets dethroned. Continuing the theme of winners earning their spots through trials and tribulations – in this case literally, with front man Randy Blythe going through a trial in the Czech Republic – is Lamb Of God a documentary that even managed to snag theatrical release in some locations.

Lamb Of God – “As The Palaces Burn”

Other noteworth DVDs that saw release this year included Metallica's 3D extravaganza “Through The Never,” The Black Dahlia Murder's “Fool 'Em All,” Between The Buried And Me "Future Sequence: Live at Fidelitorium,” and Katatonia's “Last Fair Deal Gone Night.”

Best Metal Newcomer of 2014

Last year was chock full of “new” bands from established members of the scene signed to major labels, so this year we dug more into the underground for our best newcomer:

Noveria

This Italian outfit featuring members of DGM released the debut “Risen” album back in June via Scarlet Records, which fused together power, prog, and extreme metal into an auditory extravaganza that speaks of grand things to come.

Other bands nominated included the supergroups Killer Be Killed and Panzer, as well as Gothic outfit Order of Isaz and doom band Northern Crown. A full list of all the newcomers we nominated can be found at the bottom of this article.

Best Metal Performance of 2014

With contributors scattered across the globe in different markets, it can be difficult to nail down a best performer, so when multiple people vote for the same band it means they must be putting on a hell of a show. This year our staff awarded the “best performance of 2014” to the one and only:

King Diamond

The King's over-the-top vocals and and theatrical stage effects nabbed him the win, and all despite the drama-filled departure of bassist Hal Patino (just replaced by Pontus Egberg this month).

Other nominated bands who put on a stellar live show included Ghost, At The Gates, Behemoth, Judas Priest, and Eluveitie.

Most Anticipated Release of 2015

Now that the year is ending it's time to look forward with anticipation to the storm of heavy metal coming our way. In another first for Metalunderground's year-end awards, we had loads of votes for two different bands that left all others in the dust. There was a tie that just couldn't be broken between:

Slayer AND Faith No More

With all that's been happening in the Slayer camp lately fans are waiting with baited breath to see if the band still has another masterpiece in it, while the long-awaited reunion of Faith No More fuels our nostalgia for a time when MTV still played music videos and metal fans weren't so segregated into a billion sub-genres.

While those two far and away took the lion's share of the votes, we're also looking forward to releases from Enslaved, Marduk, Moonspell, and Tool (although not officially announced by the band yet).

During the voting only one of our contributors nominated the presumed Metallica release, and while there's no doubt it will sell well no matter what, it seems like more and more fans of “real” metal have basically given up on anything good coming from these once-legendary metal forefathers, who now are more associated with “I Am The Table” than with anything from the Cliff Burton era. We'd like to hear your thoughts though – do you think Metallica will actually release the album in 2015, and will it be worth hearing?

If you want to dive into the horde of new bands that released strong debut material this year you may have missed, here's the complete list of bands we nominated in the “best newcomer” category:

Monument Of Misanthropy
Hannes Grossmann
Panzer
End Silence
Karma Rassa
Crypt Sermon
Anette Olzon
Northern Crown
Orphans of Dusk
Black Magic
Artificial Brain
Vampire
Walpyrgus
Ranger
Below
Disforia
Twilight Force
Noveria
Gladenfold
Retribution
Order Of Isaz
6:33
The Kindred
Killer Be Killed
Intervals
Wovenwar
Cognizance

What's Next?

Please share this article if you found it interesting.


12 Comments on "Metalunderground.com's Best Of 2014 Awards"

Post your comments and discuss the article below! (no login required)

Blindgreed1's avatar

Member

1. Blindgreed1 writes:

I'm sure nearly everyone who posts will complain about it, but hands down... This is the most complete and accurate list to date that I can remember.

# Dec 31, 2014 @ 12:52 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
xFiruath's avatar

Contributor

2. xFiruath writes:

A couple of top-notch albums came out this year I've had on constant rotation. I think the top for me were Scar Symmetry, Dark Funeral, Solstafir, Ne Oblivscaris, and Xerath.

# Dec 31, 2014 @ 2:21 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
deathbringer's avatar

Founder, owner & programmer

3. deathbringer writes:

I didn't really hear a lot of newcomers this year. Other than the 2 I voted for, I forgot about Killer BE Killed (should have voted for them) and Wovenwar (who I'd rather just forget again). Overall, the votes seem like a good representation of 2014 though.

# Dec 31, 2014 @ 3:17 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
spiral_architect's avatar

Member

4. spiral_architect writes:

CONGRATULATIONS TO KING DIAMOND FOR HIS BEST METAL PERFORMANCE AWARD. YOU'VE GOT TO GIVE THE MAN CREDIT FOR GOING THROUGH OPEN HEART SURGERY AND BASICALLY COMING BACK FROM THE DEAD TO GIVE US MORE BLACK METAL.

AS FAR AS METAL 2015, I AM LOOKING FORWARD TO THE FINAL BLACK SABBATH STUDIO ALBUM, HOPEFULLY WITH BILL WARD BACK ON DRUMS. IT WOULD BE NICE IF THEY COULD GET THEIR ORIGINAL PRODUCER RODGER BAIN BACK TOO, BUT I GUESS THEY HAVE SETTLED FOR RICK RUBIN. I'M STILL HOPING FOR THE BEST.

HORNS UP TO ALL MY METAL BROTHERS, IN PARTICULAR TO OUR FOUNDER DEATHBRINGER.

HAVE A METAL NEW YEAR EVERYBODY!

# Dec 31, 2014 @ 4:52 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
R10's avatar

Member

5. R10 writes:

I had Behemoths album as my top album also. The new Godflesh, At the Gates, Machine Head, Exodus albums filled out my top 5. Saw King Diamond back in October for the first time, and he put on one of the best shows I've seen in a long while.

# Dec 31, 2014 @ 6:02 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
gripper's avatar

Member

6. gripper writes:

that award trophy is bad to the bone definitely Metal
album of the year Goatwhore Constricting Rage of the Merciless
no Metallica release in 15

# Dec 31, 2014 @ 11:01 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader
7. wtf? writes:

What, not even close. The Satanist is a decent album, but best album of 2014? Lol, does not even break the top 10. I think you guys might have overlooked Tripytkon's Melana Chasmata or Opeth's Pale Communion. Geez, I can think of so many more noteworthy candidates than the satanist:

Darkest Era: Severance

Mastodon: Once more round the sun

Blackfinger: Blackfinger

Fallujah: The flesh prevails

Pallbearer/Foundation of Burden

Agalloch: serpent and the sphere (understandable since Xfiruath is clearly biased against this band with his scathing review of Marrow of the spirit)

Hell, I would listen to Sonata Arctica's Pariah's child over the new Behemoth. It's decent, but not great, and certainly not the long awaited follow up to Evengelion. Don't believe the hype people!

# Jan 2, 2015 @ 1:20 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
BrianMN's avatar

Member

8. BrianMN writes:

Greeting all. Happy New Year to all of you. I hope 2014 was good to you. Here's hoping 2015 reveals more of metals infinite mysteries.
My top pics for 2014 were....and in no particular order...

Rings of Saturn...Lugal.....the most loved/hated core band on Earth returns with more controversy, more departed members, and an awesome album.

Machine Head...Bloodstone....with gems like Sail Into The Black and Damage Inside it's impossible not to admire the skill of these vets.

Decapitated...Blood Mantra...a band that's survived more attempts by Death to claim them then the Kennedy's. I'm still convinced Vogg is a distant relative.....In the veins of Organic Hallucinosis, Mantra is an amazing release.

At The Gates...At War....reviled by many, loved by just as many....I LOVE this album and feel it out plays, out composes and outdoes SOTS in every way.

Overkill...White Devil.....viscous, catchy....the bands winning streak continues.

My album of the year goes to Septicflesh Titan.
People are complaining the album is retreading the previous two albums. I consider it a refinement. This is the problem when you define, redefine and set the bar so high that people expect you to recreate that success with every release. It can't be done.
Easily Septics most cohesive and horrifyingly brutal album to date.

Cheers all

# Jan 2, 2015 @ 10:03 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
xFiruath's avatar

Contributor

9. xFiruath writes:

#7: I actually didn't review that Agalloch album. That was one of our other contributors (The_Avant_Garde back in 2010 or 2011 I think?). I actually also didn't vote for the Behemoth album in our staff voting. My top albums went to Scar Symmetry, Dark Funeral, and Ne Oblivscaris. The Fallujah album was great no doubt, but I don't get the love for Triptykon many of our staff members have express. I've tried to listen to "Melana Chasmata" four or five times and I just can't get into it at all.

# Jan 2, 2015 @ 10:37 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader
10. wtf? writes:

Oh sh**, my bad. sorry about that. I thought you reviewed it. Anyways, still, bleh

# Jan 3, 2015 @ 5:44 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Cynic's avatar

Senior Reviewer

11. Cynic writes:

>for those of us who have been impatiently waiting since 2012 – when will God Of Atheists finally drop that debut release that we voted most anticipated two years ago?

The paaaain! Hey, at least Arcturus are saying they're going to release a new album right?!

Nice picks everyone. Will have to check out Dark Funeral's latest xFiruath.

# Jan 3, 2015 @ 6:00 PM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address
Anonymous Reader
12. buchan writes:

Triptykon had a real atmosphere and depth,also played many many times were Godflesh and Yob

# Jan 11, 2015 @ 9:11 AM ET | IP Logged Reveal posts originating from the same IP address

To minimize comment spam/abuse, you cannot post comments on articles over a month old. Please check the sidebar to the right or the related band pages for recent related news articles.